Merged datasets:
goodsignal.mtz (2.1M)
badsignal.mtz (2.1M)
overlaps.mtz (2.1M)
decay.mtz (2.1M)
icy.mtz (1.6M)

Electron density phased with the correct sites:
goodsignal.map (6.5M)
badsignal.map (6.5M)
decay.map (6.5M)
overlaps.map (6.5M)
icy.map (2.5M)

The "right" model (used to calculate the data in the first place):
right.pdb (209k)

The "right" data sets (used to generate the images):
goodsignal_pristine.mtz (2.5M)
badsignal_pristine.mtz (2.5M)
overlaps_pristine.mtz (2.5M)
icy_pristine.mtz (2.5M)
decay_pristine.mtz (2.5M)

Raw Image Data:
goodsignal.tar.gz (272M)
badsignal.tar.gz (275M)
overlaps.tar.gz (276M)
decay.tar.gz (275M)
icy.tar.gz (319M)


the mtz files are scaled and merged data processed with Wedger Elves. The maps are the results of mlphare/dm using the correct sites as run by Phaser Elves. The raw image data are also available as tarballs. All data are derived from PDB id 4TMS and the "metal sites" correspond to the sulphur positions in that file.

Summary:
dataset    fpp     solve  shelxs  shelxd  hyss  cheat   CC
goodsignal 3.0      8/8    8/28    8/11   8/8    8/8   0.82
badsignal  0.8      0/4    1/21    0/11   0/0    7/8   0.49
overlaps   3.0      8/8    8/28    8/11   8/8    8/8   0.77
decay      4.0-0.0  0/8    3/40    0/11   0/8    7/8   0.42
icy        3.0      8/8    8/22    8/11   8/8    8/8   0.72

Description:

fpp is the f" value I used for the heavy-atom sites in the run. The average fpp for the "decay" set is 3.0, exponentially decaying over 100 frames. There were exactly 8 metal sites in all cases. The 7/8 numbers indicate the number of correct sites vs the number of sites found by solve, shelx, hyss or cheating with an anomalous difference Fourier using model phases. For example, 0/4 for indicates that the program found 4 sites and none of them were right. The CC is the correlation coefficient between the map produced by Phaser Elves with mlphare/dm when given the correct 8 sites to the map calculated from the published model. Unfortunately, "cheat" requires a refined model to find the sites, so it is not a "real" heavy atom finding program.

Hints:


Answer key:
goodsignal_answer_key.tar.gz (143M)
badsignal_answer_key.tar.gz (142M)
overlaps_answer_key.tar.gz (134M)
decay_answer_key.tar.gz (142M)
icy_answer_key.tar.gz (108M)